The summer transfer window has now closed, with Premier League clubs spending a total of £870m ($1.3bn) on players. That figure means than total outgoings for the calendar year have surpassed £1bn for the first time.

But which clubs conducted the best business during the window and which clubs are left looking short this season? IBTimes UK sports editor Nick Howson reviews the best and worst deals of the transfer window.

Best transfer window deals

The Ayew brothers (Jordan and Andre) at Aston Villa and Swansea, respectively, have certainly impressed. They are two exciting players who have already produced for their new clubs.

People have criticised Manchester United for some of their deals this window, but Matteo Darmian looks a very handy player. He fills a position that has been a problem at Old Trafford since the Gary Neville days.

Matteo Darmian
Matteo Darmian has impressed at the back for Manchester United Reuters

I think the deadline day addition of Joleon Lescott was really good by Aston Villa as he had an impressive season with West Brom last year.

Glenn Murray to Bournemouth is also an excellent deal for the promoted side. I think Crystal Palace were wrong to try and move him on for someone like Connor Wickham, who has no real goal-scoring record.

Worst transfer window deals

Except for Pedro I'm not convinced by the new additions at Chelsea. Some of the signings, like Michael Hector and Radamel Falcao, are still unproven at this level. It just looks like they've tightened the purse strings a little bit and brought in unknown players.

Arsenal are the only club in the top five European leagues not to bring in an outfield player and that smacks of frugality on their part. Wenger seems indecisive on the sort of players he wants and it felt like an Arsenal transfer window in the pre-Ozil, pre-Sanchez era, where Arsenal try to make much of very little and don't get very far.

Petr Cech
Goalkeeper Petr Cech was Arsenal's only signing of the transfer window Getty Images

Everyone thinks Petr Cech is one of the best signings of the window, but maybe they've made a mistake in not reinforcing some of their weak areas, particularly in attack where Olivier Giroud has got the pressure on his shoulders all over again.

Tottenham fans as well are up in arms about their lack of forward options. That's been emphasised by Harry Kane's disappointing form at the start of the season. He hasn't scored so far and now they haven't brought in a genuine striker to accompany him.