Carrie Gracie couldn't even discuss her equal pay resignation while presenting Today
KEY POINTS
- Gracie resigned from £145,000 role as BBC's China editor.
- #IStandWithCarrie was trending after she wrote an open letter about the decision.
Carrie Gracie, the BBC's China Editor who resigned on Sunday in a gender pay gap row, was drafted in to present Radio 4's Today programme on Monday but was unable to discuss one of the biggest stories of the morning - her own departure from the BBC.
Gracie resigned from her £145,000 post because of what she described as the BBC's "secretive and illegal pay culture" in which male presenters get paid much more than their female counterparts.
She added that the corporation's top salaries were "unacceptably high" and turned down a £45,000 pay rise during a six-month battle for equal pay with her fellow male journalists.
Gracie co-presented the Today programme on Monday morning but was restricted by the BBC's impartiality rules from talking about the row.
As Times Red Box editor Matt Chorley put it: "BBC rules mean that Carrie Gracie can't discuss Carrie Gracie if Carrie Gracie is presenting the programme discussing Carrie Gracie. So she is sitting in silence while Mariella Frostrup talks about Carrie Gracie on the Today programme."
Although Gracie could not directly speak to co-presenter John Humphrys about the story, she did say the response to her resignation "speaks to the depth of hunger for an equal, fair and transparent pay system".
Some Twitter users joked about the situation being worthy of the BBC show W1A, which sends up the inner workings of the corporation at New Broadcasting House.
The official account of the Labour Whips said: "W1A are demanding they have their leaked script back."
ITV's royal editor Chris Ship replied: "It's too funny for W1A." A third user said: "W1A is having its Veep Trump moment, where things are going to become impossible to satirise."
Gracie was able to talk about her resignation as a guest on Woman's Hour although the W1A comparisons could continue as host Jane Garvey was not allowed to conduct the interview as a BBC employee. Instead, the Guardian's Jane Martinson was asked to step in.
As Garvey moved to the next segment of the programme, she said: "Impartiality does not stop me from discussing menopause on Woman's Hour next."
Gracie said: "I believe in public service broadcasting and I do think salaries at the top are unacceptably high, both for presenters and stars of various kinds and also for managers. I didn't want more money, I wanted equality and this was not equality.
"There was still a big gap between myself and my male peers. This was an exercise in understanding how the BBC approached pay, and at the end of the exercise I felt the BBC was not approaching pay in an appropriate way."

She said in her resignation letter that she had discovered the BBC's two male international editors earned 50% more than their two female equivalents. She wrote: "Despite the BBC's public insistence that my appointment demonstrated its commitment to gender equality, and despite my own insistence that equality was a condition of taking up the post, my managers had yet again judged that women's work was worth much less than men's."
#IStandWithCarrie trended on Twitter on Monday morning as people continued to react to Gracie's resignation.
Comedian Sandi Toksvig was among those sharing a message of support:
Equal Pay for Equal Work? Much too revolutionary an idea for my pretty little head. I need to lie down before I have a fit of the vapours. #IStandWithCarrie #equalpay #BBCwomen
— Sandi Toksvig (@sanditoksvig) January 8, 2018
BBC broadcaster Clare Balding responded to a statement by BBC Women, a group of journalists in the company fighting for equal pay:
Carrie Gracieâs stand is important. Itâs about respect as well as reward. We donât want future female broadcasters, journalists, reporters, commentators, editors & producers to have to fight for the right to be paid equally for doing the same job. #equalpay #IStandWithCarrie pic.twitter.com/Q3i3srZQNd
— Clare Balding (@clarebalding) January 8, 2018
See more messages of support for equal pay below:
It is a sad day for many aspiring journalists to learn that even the BBC don't pay their employees equally. @BBCCarrie has done us a favour by resigning in protest to shed a light on the #GenderPayGap. #IStandWithCarrie
— Rosie Dowsing (@Rosiedowsing) January 8, 2018
This letter by @BBCCarrie is inspiring and gut wrenching at the same time. It makes my heart sink and my blood boil to read about the long standing inequality that BBC women at ALL levels face #IStandWithCarrie https://t.co/Tbld3aGUu0
— Anne-Marie Tomchak (@AMTomchak) January 8, 2018
What a dignified & brilliant letter from @BBCCarrie & how sad & frustrating that she had to write it. Whilst men & women are systemically treated unequally in pay & promotion & parental leave lasting change will be hard to effect. #IStandWithCarrie #EqualPay
— Kerry Glencorse (@kerryglencorse) January 8, 2018
Equal Pay for Equal Work? Â Much too revolutionary an idea for my pretty little head. Â I need to lie down before I have a fit of the vapours. Â #IStandWithCarrie #equalpay #BBCwomen
— Sandi Toksvig (@sanditoksvig) January 8, 2018
Equal pay! Why should Women not have the same pay as Men, you do the same work you get the same pay.
— Fire Rosa. ð (@Fire_Rosa) January 8, 2018
Itâs 2018 FFS!
#IStandWithCarrie
Thank you to brave women like @BBCCarrie who make a stand not just for herself but for other women - we deserve equal pay for equal work now! #equalpay #IStandWithCarrie
— Rachael Stray (@Rachael_Stray) January 8, 2018
It's been 100 years since women won the right to vote. How many more years until we receive equal pay? Sitting in solidarity with BBC China editor Carrie Grace @BBCCarrie and thanking her for fighting for what is right #IStandWithCarrie #BBCWomen #EqualPay https://t.co/rsFfXlIgz6
— Liz Carr (@thelizcarr) January 8, 2018
Well done @BBCCarrie for this excellent open letter. It is awful you had to give up the job you worked hard for. But hopefully, finally, the #equalpay fight may start to finish with your actions. Please everyone read this... #IStandWithCarrie https://t.co/b06uPxipkt
— Leigh Sanders (@LSanders_Star) January 8, 2018