Tyler Warren Just Got Peyton Manning's Silent Approval — What Did the Hall of Famer QB Say to Him?

Tight end Tyler Warren, the Indianapolis Colts' first-round pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, received an unexpected nod of approval from Hall of Fame quarterback Peyton Manning during the team's training camp this week in Indianapolis. The moment took place ahead of the Colts' preseason opener and immediately drew media and fan attention, as Manning has rarely singled out rookies in such a visible way.

Warren, who has been impressing both coaches and analysts, was surprised with a signed jersey and a personalised video message from the former Colts star, further solidifying his rising status within the team.

Tyler Warren's College Career and NFL Draft Rise

Warren's journey to the NFL spotlight began with a standout senior season at Penn State, where he recorded 104 receptions for 1,233 yards, along with eight receiving touchdowns. His versatility was further showcased by four rushing scores and even one passing touchdown. He was awarded the 2024 John Mackey Award as the nation's top tight end and earned first-team All-American and All-Big Ten honours.

In April 2025, the Colts selected Warren 14th overall, making him the highest tight end draft pick for the franchise since Dallas Clark in 2003. The move raised eyebrows initially, but Warren's physicality, hands and football IQ quickly began to validate the decision during rookie minicamp and early pre-season workouts.

Peyton Manning's Personal Message

In a video posted by Fanatics, Warren was presented with a No. 18 jersey signed by Peyton Manning, along with a dedicated video in which the Hall of Famer welcomed him to the Colts. While the message was brief, it was described internally as a strong sign of endorsement, particularly given Manning's minimal involvement in public team affairs in recent years.

'It's not always easy competing in the NFL, but Colts' fans stuck with me and I know they'll be behind you every step of the way', said Manning. At the latter part of the video, Warren was seen holding the jersey signed by the Colts' Hall of Famer with visible writing, 'I am pulling for you hard!'

This gesture was not part of any scheduled media event. The moment quickly spread across social media, with fans and NFL insiders interpreting it as a symbolic passing of the torch to a new potential franchise figure.

Why Manning's Support Carries Weight in Indianapolis

Manning's voice remains influential across the NFL and particularly in Indianapolis, where he led the Colts to a Super Bowl title and multiple division championships. His relationship with the fanbase and organisation remains intact, and his rare public support of a rookie has heightened expectations around Warren's future.

The endorsement also links Warren to a lineage of elite Colts tight ends, such as Clark and Jack Doyle, but with the added pressure of following in the footsteps of a player with Manning's legacy. Manning's message adds further significance to Warren's role heading into his first professional season.

Colts Camp Buzz: Warren Impressing Early

Since the start of training camp, Warren has consistently impressed coaching staff and media observers. As reported by Sports Illustrated, Head Coach Shane Steichen recently told reporters that he 'has been phenomenal so far.' Warren's size, speed and sharp route running have made him a standout during red-zone drills.

Currently listed atop the tight end depth chart, Warren is expected to take meaningful snaps in the Colts' first preseason game. With a strong showing, he could solidify his position as the starting tight end ahead of Week 1.