Karoline Leavitt
White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt insisted the Trump administration was 'moving on' from questions about Jeffrey Epstein during Tuesday's briefing despite new FBI documents revealing Trump called police about him in 2006 Gage Skidmore/WikiMedia Commons

The White House wants everyone to stop talking about Jeffrey Epstein. That much became crystal clear on Tuesday when Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt cut off questions about newly released FBI documents showing Donald Trump rang police about Epstein back in 2006. Her message? 'We're moving on from that.'

Except that the documents that just came out make moving on a bit tricky. Because they show Trump told Palm Beach police 'thank goodness you're stopping him, everyone has known he's been doing this' when they were investigating Epstein nearly 20 years ago. Which is awkward, considering Trump spent years insisting he had no clue about any of it.

The FBI Document That Won't Go Away

An FBI report from a 2019 interview with former Palm Beach Police Chief Michael Reiter has landed the White House in hot water. Reiter's name is redacted in the document, but he's confirmed to the Miami Herald that he gave the interview and that Trump rang him in July 2006, right when the Epstein investigation became public.

According to the FBI's summary, Trump didn't just ring to say hello. 'Donald Trump told [Reiter] that he threw Epstein out of his club. Trump called the [Palm Beach Police Department] to tell him "thank goodness you're stopping him, everyone has known he's been doing this",' the document states. Trump apparently told Reiter that 'people in New York knew Epstein was disgusting', called Ghislaine Maxwell—Epstein's accomplice who's now serving 20 years for sex trafficking—'evil', and told police to 'focus on her'. The document also notes that Trump 'was one of the very first people to call when people found out that they were investigating Epstein'.

So What About All Those Denials?

Here's where it gets messy. In July 2019, when reporters asked Trump if he had any suspicions about Epstein 'molesting underaged women', he responded: 'No, I had no idea. I had no idea.'

That's a pretty definitive denial. Except now we've got an FBI document saying that back in 2006, Trump rang the police specifically to say everyone knew what Epstein was up to.

At Tuesday's press briefing, a reporter pressed Leavitt on this exact contradiction, noting Trump had claimed he had no idea about Epstein's crimes, yet during the 2006 conversation, he said 'thank goodness you're stopping him' and called Maxwell 'evil'. 'Did that conversation with Palm Beach Police happen, and can you explain the discrepancy?' the reporter asked.

Leavitt's Non-Answer Answer

Leavitt didn't confirm whether the call happened. She didn't deny it either. 'It was a phone call that may or may not have happened in 2006. I don't know the answer to that question,' she told reporters. 'What I'm telling you is what President Trump has always said, is that he kicked Jeffrey Epstein out of his Mar-a-Lago club because Jeffrey Epstein was a creep, and that remains true.'

She insisted Trump has 'remained consistent' and that 'unlike many other people who are named in these files, President Trump cut off his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein'. Then came the bit that'll make headlines: 'And I'm sure many of you, when you read that alleged FBI report, probably thought to yourself, wow, this really cracks our narrative that we've been trying to push about this president for many years. So we're moving on from that.'

When asked for comment, the White House referred them to the Justice Department. A DOJ official responded: 'We are not aware of any corroborating evidence that the President contacted law enforcement 20 years ago.' So the FBI has a document from a 2019 interview saying Trump rang him. The police chief himself has confirmed to the Miami Herald that the call happened. But the DOJ says they're 'not aware of any corroborating evidence'. Either the call happened or it didn't.

The Stories That Don't Add Up

Emails released by House Democrats last year complicate things further. In an April 2019 email to author Michael Wolff, Epstein wrote that Trump 'knew about the girls' and that Trump asked Maxwell to stop. Epstein also claimed Trump never actually kicked him out: 'Trump said he asked me to resign, never a member ever.'

Tuesday's press briefing wasn't just about Trump's 2006 call. Leavitt also had to field questions about Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who testified earlier that day that he had lunch on Epstein's private Caribbean island in 2012. Lutnick insisted he was on a family holiday and only stayed for an hour. 'Secretary Lutnick remains a very important member of President Trump's team, and the president fully supports the secretary,' Leavitt said.

If the FBI document is accurate—and both Reiter and the FBI say it is—then Trump knew enough in 2006 to ring police and say everyone was aware of what Epstein was doing. That's not the same as saying he had no idea, which is what he claimed in 2019. According to Karoline Leavitt, though, we're all supposed to just forget about it now. Good luck with that.