Vitaly
Vitaly/Instagram

Russian-American YouTuber Vitaly Zdorovetskiy remains in immigration detention in the Philippines, even after the dismissal of most criminal charges brought against him earlier this year. Known for live streaming disruptive pranks, Zdorovetskiy had faced backlash over a series of videos recorded in Manila, which led to formal complaints and criminal charges.

In a public appeal submitted in May, Zdorovetskiy apologised for his actions and cited mental health concerns, urging that the charges be dropped. While two of the three charges have since been dismissed and only one remains active, he continues to be held in custody due to unresolved immigration issues.

Charges Dismissed, But One Remains

Zdorovetskiy originally faced three counts of 'unjust vexation' related to public disruptions and alleged harassment of security personnel. The charge of 'unjust vexation' under Philippine law is broadly defined and typically applies to non-violent behaviour that causes undue annoyance or disturbance.

In a letter addressed to Interior Secretary Jonvic Remulla, he requested leniency on mental health grounds and offered a formal apology. Remulla rejected the appeal, telling 24 Oras that the actions in question could not be excused, regardless of personal circumstances.

However, the legal case has since shifted. By early July, most complainants had withdrawn or opted not to pursue charges. Only one count remains, making a protracted sentence increasingly unlikely. Reports indicate that his continued detention is now more closely tied to immigration matters than ongoing criminal proceedings.

Bail Granted, but Immigration Holds Firm

On 18 June, a Taguig court granted Zdorovetskiy bail. Despite this, he was immediately transferred to a Bureau of Immigration facility and classified as an "undesirable alien." Philippine officials confirmed that deportation proceedings are under way, but neither the United States nor Russia has yet agreed to accept his return.

His dual nationality has further complicated efforts, as both the United States and Russia have reportedly declined to accept deportation, citing procedural or jurisdictional constraints. Until such arrangements are finalised, he will remain in custody.

A photograph released in June shows Zdorovetskiy with a longer beard and a visibly thinner frame, prompting renewed scrutiny of his condition while in detention. However, public reaction has been largely unsympathetic. Many online commentators have questioned the focus on his wellbeing, pointing instead to the distress caused by his previous behaviour.

Mental Health Not Considered in Legal Process

Although Zdorovetskiy's mental health was raised as a mitigating factor during his appeal, there has been no indication that the court or immigration officials have taken it into account when considering the case. The final remaining charge has yet to be resolved, and it remains unclear whether the witness will proceed.

If the case is dismissed or dropped, Zdorovetskiy could be cleared of all criminal liability. Nonetheless, his immigration status poses a separate barrier to release. With no receiving country identified, he remains in a form of legal limbo.

Zdorovetskiy's situation reflects a dramatic shift from an initial 24-year maximum penalty to the possibility of full exoneration. Yet despite the legal reversal, his detention continues due to his immigration classification. The outcome will depend on whether the remaining charge is resolved and whether international cooperation can be secured to facilitate deportation. In the meantime, his health and ongoing confinement highlight the personal toll of an already complex international case.

Writer's pick