Group A: Malmo 1-0 Shakhtar Donetsk, Paris Saint-Germain 0-0 Real Madrid

Group B: CSKA Moscow 1-1 Manchester United, Wolfsburg 2-0 PSV Eindhoven

Group C: Atletico Madrid 4-0 FC Astana, Galatasaray 2-1 Benfica

Group D: Manchester City 2-1 Sevilla, Juventus 0-0 Borussia Monchengladbach

Kevin de Bruyne
Kevin de Bruyne secured a dramatic late winner for Manchester City against Sevilla at the Etihad Stadium AFP

So another late goal rescues City from further disappointment in Europe. That De Bruyne strike could be very important indeed in Group D, with the Premier League leaders now just a point behind Juventus following their disappointing goalless draw against Borussia Monchengladbach and three clear of Sevilla.

As for United, they were notably underpar but will be relieved to leave Moscow with a point after Martial atoned for his handball error by scoring with a stooping header. Wolfsburg now top Group B courtesy of a comfortable win over PSV Eindhoven, leaving United second and level on points with tonight's opponents.

No goals at all in the heavyweight clash between PSG and Real Madrid in Paris, but both sides look certain to qualify for the last 16. Benfica and Atletico are now level at the summit of Group C, but Galatasaray lurk menacingly.

That is all from IBTimes UK for now. Thanks for following and goodnight.



Group A

Malmo 1-0 Shakhtar Donetsk

Paris Saint-Germain 0-0 Real Madrid

Group B

CSKA Moscow 1-1 Manchester United

Wolfsburg 2-0 PSV Eindhoven

Group C

Atletico Madrid 4-0 FC Astana

Galatasaray 2-1 Benfica

Group D

Manchester City 2-1 Sevilla

Juventus 0-0 Borussia Monchengladbach


In slightly less dramatic circumstances, PSV striker Jurgen Locadia has missed an opportunity to half his team's deficit at the Volkswagen Arena as he sees a low penalty saved by Diego Benaglio.


No winning goal for United as they are held to a draw, but for the second Champions League matchday in succession rivals City have rallied late to defy an otherwise unconvincing performance and secure all three points.

While Aguero was the hero in Monchengladbach, this time record-signing De Bruyne comes up trumps as the £55m midfielder rifles a low shot past the despairing dive of Rico.


Goal: Manchester City 2-1 Sevilla (Kevin de Bruyne)


A late flurry from City as Toure forces a save from Rico and Kevin de Bruyne puts his cross just behind the run of Sterling.


A miserable night for the Kazakhstani group stage debutants as Dedechko turns Juanfran's cross beyond Eric.

Fellaini is the latest United player to be cautioned in Moscow for a blatant trip on Tosic.


Goal: Atletico Madrid 4-0 FC Astana (Denys Dedechko OG)


Fellaini comes agonisingly close to making contact with Martial's knockdown at the back post but Akinfeev is alert to clear.

A third and final substitution for CSKA as Leonid Slutsky sends on Aleksandrs Cauna in place of Alan Dzagoev.


Herrera enters the referee's notebook for a poor challenge on Musa. CSKA have made an attacking change of their own now, with striker Kirill Panchenko on for Eremenko.


One change apiece from City and United as Fernando and Memphis Depay replace Bony and Lingard.

Kolarov had already been thrown on by Pellegrini in place of Pablo Zabaleta.


Around 15 minutes remaining for someone to find a winner in Moscow, while City remain under pressure from a confident Sevilla side whose performance tonight has belied their mid-table position in La Liga.


Malmo also earlier missed the chance to secure all three points against Shakhtar thanks to Pyatov saving Nikola Djurdjić's penalty.


Elsewhere, Kruse has doubled Wolfsburg's advantage after heading in Daniel Caligiuri's centre and Atletico are in cruise control thanks to Torres' second-half chip.


A precious equaliser out of nothing for United as Martial stoops low to powerfully head home Valencia's cross off the inside of the post.


Goal: CSKA Moscow 1-1 Manchester United (Anthony Martial)


Goal: Atletico 3-0 FC Astana (Oliver Torres)


Goal: Wolfsburg 2-0 PSV Eindhoven (Max Kruse)


A rare chance for United to pull level goes begging as Rooney, who was ahead of only De Gea in terms of touches in that opening half, heads Herrera's cross straight into the arms of Igor Akinfeev. That was only their second attempt on target tonight.

Marcos Rojo was lucky not to give away a second penalty for handball minutes earlier.

At the Etihad, Konoplyanka exposes City vulnerable right-hand side once again and crosses for Gameiro but the French international heads wide.


With United toiling in search of an equaliser, elsewhere in Group B Wolfsburg have taken the lead against PSV. Naldo's deep cross is headed back across goal and Josh Guilavogui takes a touch with his knee before seeing a shot saved by Jeroen Zoet. Dost reacts quickest and is presented with the easiest of tap-ins.


Goal: Wolfsburg 1-0 PSV Eindhoven (Bas Dost)


The introduction of Fellaini has seen the Belgian slot into position behind the underwhelming Wayne Rooney, with Ander Herrera retreating back to central midfield.


We are back underway across all of tonight's fixtures as Wesley Sneijder comes within a whisker of extending Galatasaray's lead over Benfica at the Turk Telekom Arena only for the post to intervene.


A hugely disappointing first half effort from Manchester United sees Van Gaal opt to introduce Marouane Fellaini at the break. Bastian Schweinsteiger is the man to make way. A big 45 required now to avoid a second defeat in three European fixtures for the visitors.