Is Sarah Jane Nader Dating Anyone? DWTS Star's Love Life and Pete Davidson Rumours Explained

Sarah Jane Nader's love life is attracting fresh attention following her brief run on Dancing with the Stars, but there is currently no confirmed partner in the picture.

The 24-year-old Love Thy Nader star was eliminated alongside professional dancer Hailey Bills on 16 September after their Season 35 debut. Her appearance comes weeks after Nader was spotted with Pete Davidson in Brooklyn, prompting dating speculation that sources close to the pair subsequently played down. Neither Nader nor Davidson has publicly confirmed a romance.

Is Sarah Jane Nader Dating Pete Davidson?

The Pete Davidson rumours began in early August when the former Saturday Night Live comedian and Nader were seen together in Brooklyn.

The pair was reported to have had dinner at Campania, initially describing the outing as having 'first date energy.' However, a source later said Davidson and Nader were 'just friends.'

Another entertainment outlet similarly reported that footage circulating online showed Davidson opening a car door for Nader but cited a source close to the pair who maintained they were friends. Neither has since announced that the outing developed into a relationship.

The sighting followed Davidson's split from model Elsie Hewitt, with whom he welcomed daughter Scottie Rose in December 2025. Davidson and Hewitt have since reached a co-parenting agreement.

Who Has Sarah Jane Nader Dated Before?

Nader has been open about being bisexual, with her dating life becoming part of the first season of the Hulu reality series Love Thy Nader.

One storyline followed Nader bringing photographer and creative director Eliana Orly home to Louisiana for Easter. Speaking to Variety, Nader explained that introducing a woman she was dating to her extended family was significant because her sexuality had previously been largely avoided in family conversations.

She also discussed an earlier girlfriend whom she had been frightened to bring home because she feared exposing her to homophobia.

Nader has also previously been linked to Alexis Williams, a New York City deputy press secretary who appeared on Love Thy Nader.

Why Did Sarah Jane Nader Get a Female DWTS Partner?

Nader's sexuality also influenced her historic Dancing with the Stars partnership with Bills.

Executive producer Conrad Green told the media that Nader 'wanted to have a female partner,' adding that producers repeatedly returned to the chemistry between her and Bills when considering the pairing.

The partnership made Nader and Bills one of the programme's rare same-sex celebrity-professional pairings. Despite their chemistry on screen, there has been no confirmation that their relationship extends beyond friendship and their professional partnership.

The pair performed a jive to Avril Lavigne's 'Sk8er Boi' during the second night of the Season 35 premiere on Wednesday. They received 14 points from the judges before being eliminated following the combined judges' scores and public vote.

After the performance, Nader said that having two women together on the ballroom floor felt 'powerful,' adding that she hoped viewers would see that people could dance with and love whoever they wanted.

For those wondering if Nader's DWTS appearance led to a new romance, there is no publicly confirmed relationship. The Davidson speculation remains just that, with the August outing never developing into an announced romance.