Miss Universe 2025 Winner's Controversy Continues As Brother Caught On Video 'Pretending' To Be Surprised After Announcement

A new TikTok video has added fuel to the growing online debate surrounding Miss Mexico's Miss Universe 2025 victory, after viewers claimed her brother appeared to 'pretend' to be shocked in the seconds following the winner announcement.

The viral clip, filmed by a fan who was simply recording her live reaction to the final results, unexpectedly captured the brother's response in the background, prompting intense scrutiny across social media.

How the Viral Video Emerged

The video, posted by a pageant fan who was documenting her reaction to the crowning moment, shows the audience waiting for the final announcement. As the camera is angled toward her, Miss Mexico's brother appears at the edge of the frame, standing with the crowd and looking downward moments before the winner is named.

When Miss Mexico is announced as Miss Universe 2025, he looks up, smiles, and begins clapping. The moment lasts only a few seconds, but it has rapidly drawn attention on TikTok, X and Instagram, where users claimed the reaction appeared 'rehearsed' or 'too calm for a sibling hearing life-changing news'.

Mixed Reactions From Pageant Fans

Viewer interpretations have varied widely. Some users argued that the brother looked unusually composed, with comments suggesting he may have already anticipated the win before it was announced. 'He knows already,' said one user.

Others countered that the clip simply showed a natural, modest reaction that was being over-analysed due to the broader controversy surrounding this year's results. One commenter noted that 'that's how rich react.'

Several TikTok users pointed out that loud arena environments often make it difficult to hear the exact moment of the announcement, noting that the brother's attention shifting upward could simply reflect him waiting for crowd cues rather than reacting late.

Users on X also circulated slowed-down versions of the footage, attempting to determine whether his head movement indicated prior awareness. Pageant supporters, however, warned against drawing conclusions from a few seconds of incomplete footage.

Context Behind the Miss Universe 2025 Debate

Miss Mexico's win has already ignited several controversies online, with some fans debating her placement throughout the competition and questioning certain judging decisions.

Several pageant commentators have described the finals as one of the most divisive in recent years, driven primarily by high fan engagement, strong performances from multiple frontrunners and the rapid spread of reaction footage across social platforms.

The new TikTok video has now become part of this wider conversation. Clips from the coronation night have circulated globally, with supporters praising Miss Mexico's performance in the interview segment and evening-gown competition, while critics continue to analyse crowd reactions, camera angles and backstage footage.

Fans Call for Focus on Verified Footage

Despite the speculation, many pageant followers urged caution, calling for viewers to rely only on full broadcast recordings and verified event material. Others stressed that crowd behaviour inside large arenas often varies widely, and short TikTok clips rarely offer complete context.

As the debate continues, Miss Universe 2025 remains one of the most talked-about editions of the pageant in recent memory, with every new angle, fan POV and backstage clip drawing massive attention online.