Is Taylor Swift Hiding Secret Books, Lost Albums, and Baby Clues? Inside Fans' Most Unhinged Theories Yet

Taylor Swift has inspired countless theories from her fans, but some of the more recent ones circulating online have raised eyebrows for their intensity and imagination. As excitement and discussion around The Life of A Showgirl continues to grow, discussions about the most delusional or far-fetched ideas surrounding the singer have taken over social media platforms like TikTok and Reddit.

Swift's fans, often referred to as Swifties, appear to have developed a fascination with decoding her every move, lyric, and friendship—from hidden poetry books to secret pregnancies.

Theories About Joe Alwyn

One of the most widely discussed fan theories revolves around Swift's six-year relationship with British actor Joe Alwyn. Some fans have claimed that Alwyn was allegedly abusive towards Swift, even suggesting that she once made a secret distress signal for help during a televised interview. These claims, based on gestures and perceived coded messages, have never been substantiated.

There are also theories suggesting that Alwyn resented Swift's fame and pushed her into secrecy. According to these fan discussions, Swift's songs about heartbreak and new beginnings are interpreted as coded confessions about her love life, often contradicting her public statements and lyrics.

The 'Lost Album' and Sabrina Carpenter Connection

Among the most peculiar theories is the one involving a so-called 'lost album' between Swift's 1989 and Reputation eras. Fans have dubbed this unreleased record 'Karma' and claim it was secretly handed over to pop singer Sabrina Carpenter, who allegedly released it under the title EVOLution in 2016. The theory gained traction on TikTok, where users compared songwriting styles and lyrical themes, despite there being no evidence of collaboration between the two artists.

This idea has since been dismissed by most fans, but it highlights the extent to which Swift's creative output is constantly dissected. The 'Karma' theory originally stemmed from a lyric reference in her song The Archer, which some listeners believed hinted at a shelved project. Despite Swift never confirming such an album, the rumour persists in fan circles.

The 'Cruel Summer' Pregnancy Theory

Another viral but unverified fan interpretation surrounds Swift's hit Cruel Summer. A subset of fans claim that the song details an unintended pregnancy and subsequent loss. This theory uses selective lyric analysis, such as linking phrases like 'fever dream high' and 'the shape of your body' to physical symptoms of pregnancy.

According to these interpretations, the song's references to secrecy, regret, and emotional turmoil are signs of a hidden narrative about miscarriage. Fans have even tied this idea to her later song Bigger Than the Whole Sky, viewing it as a continuation of the same story. There is, again, no evidence that Swift has confirmed or even hinted at such a storyline, and the theory remains purely speculative.

The Mystery Poet and Hidden Messages

Outside of her music, a separate corner of Swift's fandom is convinced that she secretly authored a series of poetry books under a pseudonym. One viral TikTok video claims that she published four books under the name Willow Bowry, with one titled Tortured Poets. These books allegedly mirror her lyrical style, leading some fans to conclude that Swift was behind them.

Many readers of the books have noticed similarities in phrasing and emotional tone to Swift's writing, while others argue that they appear to imitate her work rather than replicate it. The theory has not been verified, and no publisher has confirmed Swift's involvement. Nonetheless, the rumour continues to circulate, drawing attention to how fan speculation can shape online sales and publicity.

Sexuality Rumours and the 'Gaylor' Theories

A long-running narrative within the Swiftie community is the belief that Swift is secretly gay, a theory known online as 'Gaylor'. Some fans claim that lyrics, friendships, and even celebrity appearances are coded hints about her sexuality.

The theories have extended to those around her, with social media users speculating about the sexuality of friends, collaborators, and even family members of her boyfriend, Travis Kelce. These claims are entirely unverified and often criticised as intrusive. Despite this, they continue to spread through social media commentary, fan edits, and speculative threads.

The Growing Culture of Fan Speculation

From theories about abusive relationships to lost albums and secret poetry, the range of speculation surrounding Taylor Swift demonstrates how deeply invested her fans are in her life and art. As Swift continues her global prominence, these theories show no signs of slowing down.