Nancy Guthrie and Savannah Guthrie
Screenshot/X

A former FBI agent has suggested that the abduction of 84‑year‑old Nancy Guthrie from her Tucson‑area home on 1 February may share characteristics with a Chilean theft ring known for targeting wealthy US neighbourhoods.

The theory was raised by retired agent Jennifer Coffindaffer, who said on X that the masked intruder seen tampering with Guthrie's doorbell camera in the early hours of 1 February resembled suspects linked to the group. Guthrie, the mother of Today co‑host Savannah Guthrie, was confirmed inside her home shortly before the device went offline; blood was later found on the porch.

Guthrie had spent the evening visiting her daughter Annie before her son‑in‑law Tommaso Cioni drove her home at 9.48pm. She entered the house, her camera recorded activity until 1.47am, and her pacemaker signal cut at 2.28am. Her phone and car remained untouched. Friends raised the alarm the next morning when she missed church. The Pima County Sheriff's Office, the FBI, and federal prosecutors have now led a multi‑agency investigation for more than five weeks, pursuing lines of inquiry ranging from local suspects to organised groups operating across borders.

Chilean Theft Ring Shadows Guthrie Abduction Probe

Coffindaffer, now a commentator who frequently analyses criminal cases, pointed to similarities between the masked figure at Guthrie's home and individuals charged in 2025 as part of a so‑called South American Theft Group. 'A number of individuals tied to the ring were charged for many high‑profile burglaries of athletes like Travis Kelce that we were tracking,' she wrote, sharing black‑and‑white CCTV footage depicting two hooded men. She added that the attire visible in the Guthrie porch video struck her as 'eerie' given the group's history of operating in affluent communities.

Her suggestion stopped short of alleging a direct connection. Coffindaffer said 'the FBI is likely considering everything at this point just like we are', emphasising that the comparison was observational rather than evidentiary.

The federal case she referenced involved seven Chilean nationals — Pablo Zuniga Cartes, Ignacio Zuniga Cartes, Bastian Jimenez Freraut, Jordan Quiroga Sanchez, Bastian Orellano Morales, Alexander Huiaguil Chavez and Sergio Ortega Cabello — accused of stealing more than $2 million from the homes of NFL players, including Travis Kelce and Patrick Mahomes, in burglaries dating back to October 2024. They were charged as part of a criminal enterprise and face up to 10 years in prison if convicted.

The imagery Coffindaffer circulated resembled elements seen in the FBI's own footage released on 10 February. That video showed a ski‑masked man of average build, estimated at 5ft 9in to 5ft 10in, wearing gloves and armed, carrying a black 24‑litre Ozark Trail Hiker backpack while pulling at Guthrie's porch camera. Black gloves recovered nearby remain part of the evidence. Online, one user responding to Coffindaffer argued that her shared image looked 'very similar' to the Guthrie suspect, though investigators have not endorsed that claim.

Sheriff Hints At Breakthrough As Pressure Intensifies

Public scrutiny surrounding the investigation has grown alongside the speculation. Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos hinted on Today that detectives may be approaching a breakthrough. 'I believe investigators are definitely closer,' he said. 'We have gathered a substantial amount of intel and leads, but it's now time to take action.' He has separately told NBC that releasing specific details could jeopardise the case, saying he 'would be very neglectful... to share that with everybody'.

Not everyone agrees with his approach. Retired SWAT lieutenant Bob Krygier criticised Nanos on a recent podcast, accusing him of making emotional statements and noting that a large majority of deputies once delivered a no‑confidence vote against him. His critique reflects a growing impatience among some observers who feel communication has been too thin given the stakes and the time elapsed.

Federal prosecutors, however, have declined to comment publicly. The Pima County Attorney's Office said only that 'veteran prosecutors... continue to work with the Pima County Sheriff's Department, the FBI, and the US Attorney's Office,' adding that ethical rules prevent further disclosure. A $100,000 FBI reward remains active, with tips directed to 1‑800‑CALL‑FBI or tips.fbi.gov.

Savannah Guthrie has returned to her studio duties while maintaining her involvement in the search. Her team said she continues to prioritise family and efforts 'to help bring Nancy home.' With porch blood, disabled technology and no confirmed sightings, the case remains highly unsettled. Coffindaffer's theory has added another possible avenue—one rooted in pattern recognition rather than proof—but it underscores what investigators face: an abduction with few certainties and an urgency that grows with every day Guthrie's pacemaker medication goes untaken.

Writer's pick